If you’re in the mood for some authentic Italian cuisine, you won’t be disappointed with the fantastic options on offer in Indy. Each of these must-visit restaurants boasts its own unique take on those classic Italian favorites, featuring fresh ingredients and homemade recipes that will leave your taste buds craving more.
Savor a drool-worthy plate of handcrafted pasta, indulge in creamy risotto, or feast on hearty meats for a true taste of Italy without leaving Indianapolis. With a variety of cozy and sophisticated settings, these top Italian restaurants in Indy are perfect for all occasions, from date night to a birthday celebration!
1. Iaria’s Italian Restaurant
For an inviting atmosphere and delectable dishes, check out the forever enjoyable Iaria’s! The menu at this beloved Italian restaurant in Indy features a wide range of expertly crafted pizzas and perfectly cooked pasta dishes. Expect friendly and attentive service, which enhances the welcoming ambiance. These fabulous qualities combined make for a perfect spot for a date night or an intimate Italian feast with friends and family!
📍 317 S College Ave, Indianapolis, IN
2. Iozzo’s Garden of Italy
If you’re looking for an exceptional Italian eatery in Indianapolis, Iozzo’s Garden of Italy is the place to be. A passion for authentic Italian cuisine is notable in every dish, including their sensational Crab Tortellini, prepared with the freshest ingredients of the highest quality. This is seen throughout their extensive menu, including their delectable desserts. We suggest concluding with their moreish Chocolate Mousse.
📍 946 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN
3. Mama Carolla’s
Nestled inside a charming home on the edges of Indy’s hip Meridian-Kessler neighborhood, head to Mama Carolla’s for a unique dining experience. The enchanting and cozy vibes makes this place perfect for date night or an intimate get together. The menu has something for everyone, from meat to seafood and vegetarian dishes! The handmade pasta is particularly noteworthy and well worth trying if you’re an aficionado of the Italian delicacy!
📍 1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN
4. Sangiovese Ristorante
Sangiovese Ristorante offers a remarkable dining experience with its authentic Italian cuisine. Serving up those classic, Italian dishes as well as unique takes on the cuisine, this restaurant is an absolute must for fans of Italian cuisine in Indianapolis. The service is top-notch, and the staff is incredibly friendly and accommodating, ensuring diners have a memorable meal every single time!
📍 2727 E 86th St #110, Indianapolis, IN
5. OP Italian
This is a wonderful Italian eatery for all the pizza-lovers in Indy! Quality and freshness are of utmost importance as reflected in the perfectly cooked dishes. The Mushroom Pizza is a flavorful favorite, whereas the Baked Lasagna and Short Rib Gnocchi are both melt-in-your-mouth delectable. There is no doubt that OP is one of the best places in Indianapolis to enjoy authentic Italian cuisine.
📍 10 S West St, Indianapolis, IN
If you’re seeking a true Italian dining experience in Indianapolis, Ambrosia should be at the top of your list. This family-owned and operated restaurant provides a cozy and inviting atmosphere that’s perfect for any occasion, from a casual meal to a romantic dinner. The menu is filled with flavorful, traditional dishes, like the perfectly cooked Bolognese or Cannoli. The wine selection is impressive, and dining al fresco on the patio is a great way to enjoy the summer months.
📍 5903 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Capri Italian Restaurant is an exceptional dining experience in Indianapolis. The food is simply fabulous, with every dish a tantalizing love letter to Italian cuisine. The ambiance is warm and cozy, adding to the overall dining experience. As for food, the Mushroom Pancetta Tortellini and Rigatoni Boscaiola are both freshly made and full of those iconic Italian flavors.
📍 2602 Ruth Dr, Indianapolis, IN
8. Sauce on the Side
For fans of the artfully folded pizza, the calzone, you have got to check out Sauce on the Side. The hip and relaxed atmosphere and creative menu has curated one of Indy’s favorite Italian experiences in the city. As the name suggests, make sure you order some sauces with your stellar calzone, like the highly recommended Fatty B or Magic Carpet Ride. It’s also conveniently located in the heart of the city, so check it out the next time you’re downtown!.
📍 130 S Pennsylvania St Suite 2, Indianapolis, IN
9. Buca di Beppo
Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant is a standout among our forever-thriving culinary scene. Upon arrival, guests are immediately greeted by hospitable staff that creates a welcoming atmosphere for a fare of fantastic Italian cuisine. The Apple Gorgonzola salad and Salmon Sorrento are standout dishes, but don’t hesitate to ask for some of the staff’s top-notch recommendations, with a lot of items being super customizable!
📍 35 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN
10. Maggiano’s Little Italy
Going above and beyond to impress with their incredible Italian food, this adored upscale chain is the perfect place for date night if you’re craving pasta or other delicious delicacies from Italy. The dishes are a true work of art, with generous portions and unbelievable flavors. Their loyal customers can’t get enough of the Mushroom Ravioli or Chicken Alfredo, desired for their impeccable taste and indulgent nature.
📍 3550 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN
The Italian cuisine scene in Indianapolis is thriving, with top-quality restaurants that will please even the most discerning palate. Whether you’re a seasoned foodie or simply looking for a delicious, hearty meal, these Italian hotspots offer an authentic taste of Italy right here in Indy! From the warmest settings to mouthwatering dishes, you’re sure to have an unforgettable culinary experience at these must-visit restaurants.