Indianapolis has a bustling Mexican food scene that caters to both foodies and families alike. Experience amazing cuisine backed up by excellent customer service and enchanting ambiances that’ll transport you to the heart of Mexico.
Expect nothing but fresh ingredients, authentic flavors, and a variety of dishes to choose from. From simple street tacos to luxurious platters full of those iconic flavors, these Mexican restaurants have got you covered. So, here are some of the absolute best Mexican eateries in Indy that you need to check out.
1. El Jalapeño
Kick-start your culinary adventure to find Indy’s best Mexican restaurant by checking out El Jalapeño. Expect those classic dishes like Shrimp Fajitas, which are the definite favorite among the establishment’s loyal fanbase. Be sure to browse the daily specials for more unique offerings, and you have to try the tangy margaritas here!
📍 4902 S East St #1654, Indianapolis, IN
2. La Parada
La Parada serves up some of the tastiest and most authentic Mexican food in Indianapolis. The restaurant boasts a wide variety of dishes, from their adored tacos to brilliant burritos. With options for meat-lovers and vegetarians alike, there’s something for everyone! The space is small, but it adds to the authentic and intimate ambiance of this beloved restaurant.
📍 1642 E New York St A, Indianapolis, IN
This exceptional Mexican restaurant in Indianapolis offers outstanding food and exceptional customer service. Their short and simple menu packs a mighty punch thanks to those striking flavors, conjured using the freshest ingredients. Their beautiful décor adds to the enjoyable atmosphere, perfect for any special occasion, like a family dinner or fun date night.
📍 11 W Maryland St, Indianapolis, IN
If you’re looking for an enjoyable dining experience in Indianapolis, Loco Mexican Restaurant and Cantina won’t disappoint. Known for its lively ambiance and efficient service, this restaurant also offers a fantastic selection of food and beverages. The Veggie Chimichanga has become a popular dish among vegetarians, and the presentation of the dishes is always drool-worthy.
📍 2205 N Delaware St #105, Indianapolis, IN
La Hacienda Mexican Restaurant is a must-visit spot in Indianapolis. This place provides a warm welcome and fresh and tasty food in a relaxed, charming, and pleasant environment. Whether it is an early lunch or late-night feast, La Hacienda is the perfect spot to indulge in the rich and authentic flavors of Mexican cuisine.
📍 6825 Graham Rd, Indianapolis, IN
Festiva is a Mexican restaurant in Indianapolis that stands out due to its exceptional ambiance, food, and service. Customers love authentic dishes like their amazing tacos. They also rave about the unique and flavorful Costillas, which are another highlight on the extensive menu. It’s truly a must-visit restaurant for those seeking an exceptional Mexican dining experience.
📍 1217 E 16th St, Indianapolis, IN
7. El Azabache
For a lively atmosphere with upbeat music and those vibrant Mexican dishes, check out El Azabache. The restaurant has a unique charm, with stunning indoor decoration. This is another great option for vegetarians, but we love their Seafood Chimichanga, which is topped with their incredible white queso. The margarita selection here is also worth exploring!
📍 4200 S East St #11, Indianapolis, IN
This unparalleled Mexican restaurant serves up a range of wonderful dishes that will leave you craving for more. Highlights on the menu include their Street Tacos, with an extensive selection of combinations that are both traditionally familiar, yet innovative and new. Their homemade hot sauce is an absolute must-try if you like things spicy.
📍 5763 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN
9. La Piedad
La Piedad is a wonderful and cozy Mexican restaurant in Indianapolis that offers a truly authentic experience. The place has a relaxed and comfortable atmosphere, perfect for a quick lunch or a leisurely dinner. Enjoy your meal on the patio or indoors, but make sure to order one (or a few) of their moreish margaritas!
📍 6524 Cornell Ave, Indianapolis, IN
Los Cuates is a must-visit restaurant located in East Indianapolis. Its delicious food and excellent service has earned its reputation as one of the city’s many hidden gems. Many customers love the fantastic flavor of Los Cuates’s dishes, which include classic Mexican favorites like Enchiladas and Carne Asada Burritos.
📍 6429 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN
Get your taste buds ready to explore Mexican culture in Indianapolis through its rich and exciting cuisine. Eat some delicious food as you explore this vibrant city. Expect hearty portions and some of the most unique recipes that stray from the traditional dishes. This is the perfect opportunity to find your next favorite spot and enjoy the lively ambiance while savoring some of the best tacos, nachos, burritos, and margaritas that Indy has to offer!