This heartland city is home to a surprisingly vibrant and delicious seafood scene. Nestled in the heart of the Midwest, Indianapolis may not have the luxury of being located by the coast, but that doesn’t stop it from serving up some of the most delectable seafood dishes in the country.
From succulent seafood boils to flaky fish, the city’s top seafood restaurants boast an array of culinary treasures that will transport you straight to the shore. Whether you’re a seafood lover or a curious foodie, Indianapolis’s seafood restaurant scene is a hidden gem waiting to be explored.
This beloved restaurant in Indianapolis is one of the city’s favorite spots for seafood. Pier 48 Fish House and Oyster Bar surpass expectations with its delectable dishes and inviting ambiance. Indulge in the exquisite Twin Crab Cakes, succulent Stuffed Salmon, or tantalizing Black Pepper Tuna, each a delightful taste of their standout menu of innovation and some of the freshest seafood in Indy.
📍130 S Pennsylvania St Suite B, Indianapolis, IN 46204
The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar is a go-to local chain here in Indianapolis that’s perfect for seafood enthusiasts. Freshness takes center stage at this establishment, with an array of mouthwatering seafood offerings. Succulent lobster tails and flavorful crawfish teleport your taste buds straight to the ocean shores, without stepping outside of The Hoosier Capital.
📍2801 Lake Cir Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46268
Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply indulging in a seafood feast, Crab 99 is the destination to satisfy your cravings. The ambiance effortlessly combines comfort and sophistication, immersing you in a relaxing and upscale dining experience with seafood culinary classics, like their unrivaled crab dishes and other delicious delicacies.
📍14 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
If it’s tantalizing seafood boils you’re after, then Blue Crab Juicy Seafood is the restaurant for you. The service is prompt and welcoming, creating an inviting ambiance with graffiti-clad walls and nautical decor that adds an edgy charm. We recommend trying out a couple of their boozy cocktails no matter what you order, but have that designated driver at the ready!
📍8340 Kelly Ln, Indianapolis, IN 46250
Slapfish is a hidden treasure in Indianapolis, known for its delectable seafood offerings. Their Lobster Roll is served with expertly-seasoned lobster, nestled within a warm and buttery roll. With a diverse menu of fresh and flavorful seafood options, it’s a cozy go-to for fantastic seafood, so be sure to check it out if those comprehensible cravings arise.
📍345 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
This is not your average seafood restaurant, it’s an unparalleled gastronomic voyage. The Oceanaire Seafood Room has a sophisticated and upscale ambiance that makes it perfect for a romantic evening on date night. From the impeccably prepared Fried Calamari Mix to the artfully presented Crab Cakes, the attention to detail is evident throughout their fabulous menu.
📍30 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
7. Salt on Mass
Every dish at Salt on Mass is a testament to the restaurant’s artistry, crafted with the freshest ingredients for an unforgettable meal. As well as top-notch seafood, you can expect sizzling steaks, crafty cocktails, and more. However, the Diver Scallops are bathed in a luscious lemon butter sauce and are an absolute dream.
📍505 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Rick’s Café Boatyard boasts an extensive menu with a Signature Seafood selection that is the star of the show. Diving into the depths of culinary excellence, we recommend kickstarting your feast with their alluring Shrimp Cocktail. The reservoir views elevate your experience, and make it one of the best spots for a waterfront date in Indianapolis.
📍4050 Dandy Trail, Indianapolis, IN 46254
Indianapolis’s seafood restaurants offer a delightful escape from the landlocked reality of the Midwest. With their dedication to sourcing the freshest seafood and preparing it with creativity and flair, these must-visit establishments prove that you don’t need an ocean view to enjoy a memorable seafood dining experience.